Best Men's Winter Boots of 2024

THE TOP RATED MEN’S WINTER BOOTS FOR WARMTH, WATER RESISTANCE, FIT, COMFORT, and ICE TRACTION

We set rigorous criteria for what makes a good winter boot, then tested the most promising models in rugged conditions. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

January 8th, 2024
Home > Gear Reviews > Footwear

From Maine to Alaska, we trudged through ice and snow in search of the best men’s winter boots to keep feet warm, dry and comfortable.

Focusing on warmth, water resistance, fit, comfort, and traction, we narrowed the contenders down and chose top winners for every type of outdoor activity and budget.

Whether you’re looking for the best waterproof boots, the best boots for ice, insulated boots for extreme cold, boots for wide feet, or you need a solid overall pair you can do it all in, our list includes more than a dozen options to keep your feet happy until spring.

Looking for women’s boots? See our guide to Best Women’s Winter Boots


We create reader-supported, objective gear reviews independently selected by our editors. This story may contain affiliate links, which help fund our website. When you click on the links to purchase gear, we may get a commission — without costing you an extra cent. Thank you for supporting our work and mission of outdoor coverage for every body! Learn more.


Men’s Winter BOots Summary Table

MEN'S WINTER BOOTS TREELINE AWARD MSRP* INSULATION SHAFT HEIGHT TEMPERATURE RATING CLOSURE WATERPROOF?
Sorel Caribou Best Overall
Read why
$200 Removable 9 mm washable felt inner boot 9.25" -40 F Lace Y
Blundstone 500 Boots Best for City Walking
Read why
$210 None (insulated version has 200g Thinsulate) 4.5" None stated (insulated version also unrated) Slip On, over-the-ankle Y
L.L. Bean Flannel Lined Insulated Boot Best Insulated for City Walking
Read why
$219 200 g Primaloft 8" None stated Lace Y
Kamik Nation Plus Boot Best for Hiking
Read why
$250 Thermal reflective lining, 200 g insulation 7" -25 F Lace Y
Muck Boot Arctic Sport Boots Best for Working Outside
Read why
$190 5 mm neoprene, fleece lined 13" or 16.5" -40 F Pull on Y
Xtratuf Legacy 15" Best Slip On Non-Insulated
Read why
$150 None (insulated version has polymeric foam) 12" or 15" Not stated (insulated version -10 F) Pull on Y
Keen Revel IV Polar Best for Wide Feet
Read why
$190 KEEN.WARM recycled PET insulation Over the ankle and mid calf versions -25 F Lace Y
Merrell Thermo Chill Mid Shell Waterproof Best Affordable
Read why
$110 200 grams M Select™ WARM Over the ankle Not stated Lace Y
Glerups Boot with Rubber Sole Slippers Best Winter Slipper
Read why
$155 Felted wool Over the ankle Not stated (insulated version -10 F) Slip On Y
Blundstone Thermal All-Terrain $279 Leather Over the ankle Not stated (insulated version -10 F) Slip On
Kamik Greenbay 4 $90 8 mm Thermal Guard removable liner 14.25" -40 F Pull on Y
Timberland 6 Inch Premium Waterproof Boot $210 None 6" Not stated Lace Y
UGG Butte Boot $240 17mm UGGpure™ wool lining 8.5" -20 F Lace Y
Salomon X Ultra 4 Mid Winter Thinsulate Waterproof $165 Thinsulate Over the ankle -13 F (limit) Lace Y
Baffin Impact Winter Boots $250 8-layer liner system 15" -148 F Pull on with adjustable straps Y
SOURCE: Manufacturers

* Prices reflect MSRP and are subject to change. We note any discounts we see on our Deals page, which is updated daily.


The Best Men’s Winter Boots

the Best Men’s Winter Boot: Sorel Caribou

Insulation: Removable 9 mm washable felt inner boot with snow cuff

Shaft Height: 9.25"

Temperature Rating: -40 F

Footwear Closure: Lace

Waterproof: Yes

What we liked: long-term durability, high quality construction, insulation suited for extreme cold, grip, range of sizes available

What we didn’t like: weight, doesn’t feel as snug due to amount of insulation

The Sorel Caribou boots have been kicking winter’s butt since the 1960s. And boy, can they pack a wallop. While known for their clunky-chore-boot charm, the Caribous have been keeping our toes ultra- toasty and feet dry in an 80 year spree with no end in sight. My father has owned his pair of Sorel Caribous since 1992. I’ve never seen a winter without him wearing those boot — from New York to Colorado to Maine! In fact, many reviewers brought up family members having owned these boots for 15+ years, and still going strong.

They’re so beloved that they are also the Winner of our Women’s Winter Boot for Extreme Cold—and had the Sorel Caribou not won our overall best winter boot award, we’d give it the award for Best for Extreme cold, too!

The Sorel Caribou are the classic winter boot that keeps you warm, last forever, and can handle winter yard work. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

The Sorel Caribou are the classic winter boot that keeps you warm, last forever, and can handle winter yard work. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

Liner and insulation

The removable liner (handy if you want to clean it, or replace them after 20 years of tromping through snow, like my dad finally did) is made from 9mm ThermoPlus™ insulation, which features four layers of protection — polypropylene, foil, polyester, and viscose.

According to hundreds of reviewers, there are no warmer boots on the market. Outdoor Gear Lab says, “[The Sorel Caribou] provides ample warmth in the double negative digits.” These boots are rated by Sorel down to -40℉; the author can tell you they’re quite comfy down to at least -20℉; her father heartily concurs. That’s why we say if the Caribou boot had not won best overall, it’d be our winner for best for extreme cold.

Our second choice for best overall was the classic L.L. Bean insulated duck boot, but in the end, we found that the Sorel Caribous were more highly rated as a classic men’s snow boot—and warmer, too. The Caribou is also more comfortable as a work boot. You’ll find the Duck Boot as our winner for best insulated for city walking (below).

Traction and coverage

While most will agree that these boots are a tad heavy to be wearing on a multi-mile winter hike, others ignore that statement and take off into the woods sporting their beloved Caribous. The tread on the Caribous was one of the best grips on packed snow in Outdoor Gear Lab’s tests, while the felt cuff and mid-calf shaft kept the snow, slush, and puddles far away from reviewers’ feet. 

Replaceable fleece-lining on the Caribous means that you can keep using these boots for decades. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

Replaceable fleece-lining on the Caribous means that you can keep using these boots for decades. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

Fit

The biggest gripe (although some would argue that it’s a plus in their books) with the Sorel Caribou boot is that they are not a close fit. They are designed to be looser than most boots, both for ease of use pulling on/off, and to give room for various socks.

The insulation also impacts the fit. Since that felt liner is so thick (comparatively, the nubuck upper is pretty thin) the boot feels more like a fluffy casing around your ankle and foot, rather than close-fitted support that you would find in, say, hiking boots.

Combined with their weight, the lack of “hug” around your foot might cause your foot to feel loose and move around the boot. (Sorels tend to run a bit large, but we suggest staying with your true shoe size, even if you wear thick socks. I tend to wear thin socks, so I went down a half size and was perfectly content.) Their “clunkiness” may not make them ideal for everyone, but for those who need to keep their feet warm and dry, these are a must-have. 

The Sorel Caribou are the classic winter boot. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

The Sorel Caribou are the classic winter boot. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

Sizes

For the gentlemen with larger feet than most shoe stores will carry, never fear. While some stores make up to size 15 available, Sorel also makes a Caribou Boot, that runs up to size 17! Because, as XLFeet.com said, “[W]e the big men of the world deserve warm dry feet too.”



Blundstone 500

Best Men’s for city walking:  Blundstone CLASSIC Boots

Insulation: none (insulated version available)

Shaft Height: 4.5”

Temperature Rating: none stated (insulated version also unrated)

Footwear Closure: slip on, over the ankle

Waterproof: yes

What we liked: classic look, well-made, lasts many years and becomes more comfortable with more wear, waterproof

What we didn’t like: not suited for extreme cold or deep snow

If you’re looking for a winter boot that can go from the office to the barn and onto the bar, the Blundstones may very well be the best choice for you. Winter meets its match with our most style-forward winner in the Blundstone Classic Chelsea boot series.

While some might say these should stay in the city, these leather boots have strutted down mountain-town main streets and stomped around National Forest campgrounds, alike—all while keeping toes warm, dry, and hip.

Although an Australian-based company, Blundstone offers plenty of warm options. Love the Blundstone look but need more insulation? We also tested the Blundstone All-Terrain Thermal winter boot, a thermal waterproof boot with Thinsulate and shearling insulation. You can read our in-depth review on those Blundstone boots here.

Blundstones look great new but get that “classic” look after they are worn in.

Blundstones look great new but get that “classic” look after they are worn in.

ease of slipping on

We would have chosen the Blundstone chelsea boot as our best slip-on boot, but the ankle-high design made us hesitate to choose them for the slip-on category (which often is used for farm work more than urban city walking). Regardless of designation, the Blundstones are a breeze to slip on and off. While the majority of the boot is leather, the stretchy sides are made of elastic to aid with easy on-and-off. Front and back loops add to the ease.

style and comfort

Like the L.L. Bean Stonington boot or L.L. Bean 10” Bean Boot that we also considered for this best men’s winter boots for city walking, Blundstone hasn’t changed much about these casual boots in their 150 years of business.

With a few technological upgrades—like their cushioning Shock Protection System (SPS) midsole—they’ve kept the classic look while keeping the footwear relevant for a new era. SPS is designed to disperse shock when your foot strikes the ground, which reduces the amount of stress to your skeletal system. (Read: comfier, happier feet and joints!) 

Blundstone 500 sideview

Blundstone leather boots also come with a removable, anatomically-correct EVA footbeds for extra cushion and support. The soles hold a 4mm tread for good grip on ice, slush, mud, and pavement alike. The soles also hold a steel shank that runs down the middle, which provides enough rigidity to lend support and stability to these ankle boots. 

Keep in mind that their half-sizes are no longer, only wider than the full sizes (ex: a 7.5 is the same length as a 7, but slightly wider), and that some places sell Blundstones in their traditional Australian sizes. Make sure to check the country-specific sizes before purchasing! 


BEST MEN’S CASUAL INSULATED: L.L. Bean Flannel-Lined Insulated

Insulation: 

Upper Lining: 100% cotton brushed chamois cloth; 7.5 oz per sq. yd.

Bottom Unit Lining: Cambrelle (synthetic knit)

Insulation: 200 grams of Primaloft

Shaft Height: 8”

Temperature Rating: none stated 

Footwear Closure: lace-up, over the ankle

Waterproof: yes

What we liked: classic duck boot look, cozy flannel lining, tall enough to survive slush, laces up tight against snow, leather, handmade in Maine

What we didn’t like: not suited for extreme cold or deep snow, runs large, flannel retains moisture, water can seep in through tongue gusset 

Wicked winters call for a Nor’Eastern classic: the L.L. Bean duck boot. But if your toesies can’t handle what the Downeast brings, L.L. Bean upped the ante with one of their coziest options—a flannel-lined leather boot, perfect for winter walks to collect pine boughs in  snow-covered woods, or scooting around the corner to your favorite eatery. Need to throw on a pair of boots to head out to the grocery store or pick up the kids from school? Say no more–slip your feet in, lace them up (or don’t, you rebel) and brave those northern snowdrifts. 

We love these boots for their chic versatility. They’re functional, waterproof (but don’t jump in too deep a puddle), yet stylish enough to wear around town, even in the foulest of weather. (They’re made for the coast of Maine—can you tell?)

WARMTH AND INSULATION

While we laud the classic un-lined Bean boot, we appreciate the 200 grams of Primaloft and soft cotton of the flannel lining found in the Flannel-Lined Insulated Bean Boots. However, because that cozy flannel is also 100% cotton, this lining can hold onto moisture for far longer than a synthetic lining would—keep that in mind if you run warm, or plan to wear these boots through deep, heavy snow. There is a Gore-Tex and flannel-lined option as well, although we have not had an opportunity to test that boot yet. 

WATERPROOFNESS

The tumbled leather feels soft and buttery without losing its waterproof qualities, while the chain-like tread offers great traction, even on ice. (Our tester proved it by doing push-ups on an icy New Hampshire lake.) Each boot is handmade in Brunswick, Maine, and the quality is unparalleled—as is the demand for these boots as soon as the temps drop below 60. 

DURABILITY

As for durability, L.L. Bean has promised a sturdy boot for over 100 years, and they continue to deliver. Our Massachussetts-native tester has owned (and thrashed) his pair of flannel-lined Bean boots for 8 years and counting, and still calls them “the waterproof-est and only boot I’ll wear in New England winter. But if you run warm, beware a little boot sweat.” He suggests sizing down a half-size at least, unless you plan to wear expedition-weight wool socks with them, as these boots do run large. 

VALUE

The Blundstone All-Terrain Thermal winter boot was a close second for the L.L. Bean Duck Boot for best insulated city walking shoe. You can read our in-depth review on those Blundstone boots here.

Ultimately, the Duck Boot is less expensive, comes with one of the outdoor industry’s best warranties, and is made in the US. It also has more size, height, and color options than the Blundstone. That’s why we chose it as best insulated winter boot for city walking.


The Kamik Nation Plus men’s winter boot are a great budget boot option

BEST MEN’S WINTER BOOTS FOR HIKING: KAMIK NATION PLUS

Insulation: 200g Thinsulate insulation

Shaft Height: 12”

Temperature Rating: -40F

Footwear Closure: Lace

Waterproof: Yes

What we liked: Snow tire-esque tread and great grip, tall shaft for keeping out snow, wide sizing available, value for the price

What we didn’t like: Can still absorb water at heights over 4.5”

None of us like slipping on snowy surfaces, and Kamik decided they’d had enough. The Kamik Nation Plus men’s winter boots won our award for the Best Winter Boots for Hiking thanks to their snow tire-like tread and their grippy-rubber soles. The sub-$100 price didn’t hurt our decision, either. While the Kamik Nation Plus boots still had their downfalls—not entirely waterproof, for one—these budget-conscious boots would make a great investment for a few seasons of slick weather. 

Bonus—these boots almost were our winner for Best for Wide Feet because of their generous sizing options. That’s great news for winter hikers.

insulation and warmth

The Kamik Nation Plus winter boots feature HEAT-MX™ material that wicks away moisture to help keep you dry and warm, as well as lofted Thinsulate insulation for uber warmth. Thick rubber soles keep your feet well above the cold ground, while extended rubber over the tops of your toes effectively keeps snow, slush, and ice from seeping in during hikes. 

Kamik claims they’re rated down to -40F thanks to their insulating efforts. At a price you can’t beat, this boot packs above its weight in the warmth category. Bonus points for its removable 200-gram liner.

fit and sizing

These boots run stiff and don’t have a lot of cushion for your feet; if you’re worried about comfort, you may need to get an insert for hiking. See our guide for hiking insoles and footbeds for more info on whether an insert can help with comfort. Most reviewers advise to size up, as they tend to run small. This is consistent with how we recommend folks size hiking boots, too.

Bonus: this is one of few winter boots that comes in wide sizing.

TREAD AND TRACTION

Here’s what we really appreciated about the Kamik Nation Plus as a hiking boot: the treads. Rubber is one of the best grips for winter boots, since it won’t freeze and grips onto slick surfaces well. (Or, as well as anything can grip onto slick surfaces.)

The rubber treads on the Kamik Nation Plus boots are designed a lot like snow tires—the tread pattern allows you to hold onto a bit of snow, similar to a ski pole, while also maintaining enough contact points in key areas of your feet to help keep you upright on icy spots. As Outdoor Gear Lab said, “Every time we thought we had found a boot with good grip on the ice, we would slip the Nation Plus on the other foot and test them side by side, and every time the Nation Plus was among the grippiest.” 

Waterproofing

The suede uppers and rubber bottoms are waterproof and the seams are sealed, but testers from Outdoor Gear Lab found that water would still seep through the tongue gusset in puddles above 4.5”.

What does that mean for you? Laced up against the snow, these boots should prove hardy enough to slog through a blizzard, but stepping into slush—or a heavy, wet snow—could see seepage of water into your boot after a chunk of time. Wet feet can lead to frozen feet, so waterproofness is key when it comes to winter boots. However, if you’re not planning to take these boots on a multi-night trip through the Canadian wilderness in January, you should be good for shorter stints or icier conditions.

If you still aren’t sure about wearing shoes that let water seep in over 4.5” for winter hiking, see tips from our guide on What to wear winter hiking. Depending on the amount of snow, length of hike, temperatures, where you’re hiking, and your goals, waterproof socks and gaiters can often be all you need to add to your hiking kit up to be comfortable in some winter conditions.

The truth is that in some conditions, even with waterproof boots, your feet will become wet from sweating. We think traction is something that is much harder to manage for in a boot. For that reason, we think the Kamik Plus are great winter boot for hiking.

Think about where you’re hiking and for how long, do some risk assessment, and choose from there. For most hikers, we think the Kamik Nation Plus will be all you’ll need—and at a great price.


Muckboot Arctic Sport Boots warmth, traction—all at a remarkable price.

Best MEN’S WINTER BOOTS FOR WORKING OUTSIDE: Muck Boot Arctic Sport Boots

Insulation: 5 mm neoprene, fleece lined

Shaft Height: 13” or 16.5”

Temperature Rating: -40F

Footwear Closure: Pull on

Waterproof: Yes

What we liked: very convenient when working outside and coming inside back-and-forth throughout the day, waterproof, warm, easy slip on/pull off, arch support

What we didn’t like: heel rubbing, tight on wider shins after prolonged use

If you don’t want to deal with lacing up your boots every time you go outside, the Muck Boot Arctic Sport Boots are for you. The Muck Boot Arctic Sports are warm, waterproof, durable, and exactly what you want on your feet in harsh conditions and extreme cold. Called the workhorse of the men’s boot world for a reason, the Arctic Sports are way less of a fashion statement than our winner for City Walking, the Blundstones, or L.L.Bean Boots, but infinitely more functional. (Think: what farmers in frigid Iowa wear to make sure they’re not going to get frostbitten at chore time.) 

The Muck Boot viewed from the front.

While definitely on the heavier side for winter boots, the Arctic Sports are filled with 5mm of neoprene insulation, are lined with fleece, and have 2mm of thermal foam under the footbed for supreme warmth. They also have a super-comfortable EVA midsole for arch support and aid with traction and grip. (The better connected your foot is to your boot, the easier it is to maintain traction on slippery ground!)

These are another classic cold states snow boot that I’ve seen from working outside from Alaska to Michigan to New Hampshire. “They're meant for real winter conditions,” one of my friends told me on a casual -15℉ morning in icy Iowa. “People in the cold states rave about them. They’re great with windchill deep snow, and super comfy when I’m hiking around the farm all day.” 

One of the biggest questions from reviewers was, “Why Muck over Boggs?” The answer is, these Muck Boots are way warmer. The rubber outsole on the Arctic Sports is thicker, which insulates you more effectively from cold ground. They have more insulation (remember that 5mm of the stuff?) to boot.

In the end, it’s a personal preference (some people are die-hard Boggs fans, à la Yankees aficionados) but our research turned up the Muck Boot Arctic Sports with more reviews overall, and more positive reviews for working in harsh winter conditions. There were mentions amongst reviewers of some heel rubbing and marks left on their shins with extended wear, but they were not extremely prevalent. 


Best Slip-On Winter Boot — Non-Insulated: Xtratuf Legacy 15"

xtratuf legacy winter boot

Insulation: none

Shaft Height: 12” or 15”

Temperature Rating: none stated

Footwear Closure: pull on

Waterproof: yes

What we liked: waterproof, unbeatable traction, very comfortable, great arch support, versatility throughout cooler months

What we didn’t like: not as warm as other boots

The Xtra Tuf Legacy is the Alaskan staple that’s leaked out from PNW to the rest of the world. (I’ve seen them as far away as Japan.) Designed for fishermen on the brutally cold seas off of the Alaska coast, these boots are as waterproof as you’re going to find. With insulated and non-insulated options, these are the ultimate winter boots for those who live with heavy, wet snow — especially along coastlines. The non-insulated options work well in shoulder seasons, warmer winters, or just plain wet snow.

The non-insulated options work well in shoulder seasons, warmer winters, or just plain wet snow. While there were more praise-filled reviews for our best insulated slip-on winner, the Muck Boot Arctic Sport II, we wanted to find a good option for those who don’t want an insulated option. And, we couldn’t leave out the author’s go-to winter and rain boot. (Seriously — I spend 200+ days a year in them.) For more details, read my long-term, in-depth review on the Xtratuf Legacy boots.

Rafting in Alaska in the Xtratuf Legacy boots on the river in Alaska.

Rafting in Alaska in the Xtratuf Legacy boots on the river in Alaska.

HEIGHT OPTIONS AND VERSATILITY

While Xtra Tufs come in a range of heights, our favorite is the Legacy 15”. Fifteen inches is tall enough to keep out even deep puddles, but the waterproof triple-dipped neoprene rubber shafts (which are more malleable and lighter than traditional rubber) allow you to roll them down for both fashion or sweaty feet. At that height, the Xtra Tuf Legacies settle comfortably at the top of the calf in a snug but not restrictive manner. 

The Legacy boots come in different lengths, but we tested the 15”—among the tallest boots we considered. It’s also available in shorter lengths including ankle. Photo by Josette Deschambeault.

The Legacy boots come in different lengths, but we tested the 15”—among the tallest boots we considered. It’s also available in shorter lengths including ankle. Photo by Josette Deschambeault.

FIT AND COMFORT

Xtra Tuf waterproof boots are known for their performance fit around the ankle and foot as both a rain boot and a winter boot. For best fit, we recommend going down about a half size. (The author generally wears a 9-9.5, and wears a 9 in Xtra Tufs.) This prevents heel rubbing and blisters, and the thick soles give you great arch support. The author used to hike 4-8 miles every day in them, 5 days a week. If you plan to wear thicker socks with the Legacies, then stick with your true street size. 

The Legacy 15” provides just enough warmth on cooler days. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

The Legacy 15” provides just enough warmth on cooler days. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

WARMTH

The Legacies are lined with a thin layer of nylon to protect your toes from cold rubber. But as Outdoor Gear Lab warns, “Added warmth is not a priority with these boots.”  (They do come in insulated options, which help out, but are pretty bulky!)

Be warned: the non-insulated boots are not a good option for those whose feet get cold easily! These boots are great for those who run warm or for wet winter weather that’s above freezing. Your toes may get very cold, otherwise, as uninsulated rubber does not hold heat well. But a lot of winter weather in the Pacific Northwest and other parts of the country is actually just wet above freezing—that’s why this boot is so popular in Alaska and beyond. It’s just enough warmth but not too much.

Xtratuf’s were designed for traction on wet boat decks in Alaska, so their soles provide some of the best stick of any of the boots we considered. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

Xtratuf’s were designed for traction on wet boat decks in Alaska, so their soles provide some of the best stick of any of the boots we considered. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.


Keen Revel IV polar boots are the best men’s winter boots for wide feet. Here they are in brown with a black thick sole

Best Winter Boot for Wide Feet: Keen Revel IV Polar

Insulation: KEEN.WARM recycled PET insulation

Shaft Height: over the ankle, mid calf

Temperature Rating: -25 F

Footwear Closure: Lace

Waterproof: Yes

What we liked: very wide and works with thick socks, flexibility, ankle support, warmth

What we didn’t like: if you don’t have wide feet, fit can feel sloppy

The Keen Revel IV Polar boots were made wide, which might not appeal to a broad audience, but to those who need the extra space, these boots are a godsend. They’re a winner for Best Winter Boot for Wide Feet for a reason—if you’ve tried other winter boots and didn’t find they worked for your feet or with your preferred favorite comfy pair of thick socks, these are the boots for you!

FIT AND WIDTH

That’s not to say that the average-width foot couldn’t wear these boots and be happy, but the overwhelming majority of reviews that we read warned about needing thick socks to make these boots work for narrower feet. (The word “sloppy fit” was used a lot in regard to narrow-footed testers.) However, wide-foot testers were thrilled at the comfort, warmth, and support that they found in these boots — and that’s why we had a clear winner for our Best Boots for Wide Feet category.

WATERPROOFNESS

Besides their roomy interior, the Keen Revel IV Polar boots stood the test of time for waterproofness, ankle support, and warmth. With waterproof leather exteriors that lend style and support, and nylon panels to add flexibility, these boots are best known for their KeenDry technology — brushed polyester linings wick sweat away, and allows for breathability while still keeping water out.

WARMTH AND COMFORT

For warmth, they sport 200 grams of KEEN.DRY waterproof, breathable polyester insulation that Keen rates down to -25°F during active use, comfortably. (The Eco Anti-Odor natural odor control in the toes doesn’t hurt, either.)

The compression-molded EVA midsole provides shock absorption and cushioning, (much like the Columbia Bugaboots), and the internal shank gives comfortable support for long days walking around. 

Our biggest gripe about this boot (besides the wide fit for those with narrow feet) were the laces. The combination of loops and hooks was frustrating to some, especially re-threading new laces. However, if this is the largest complaint, that’s not saying too much!


best winter slipper: GlerupS Wool Boots with Rubber Soles

Insulation: Felted wool

Shaft Height: Over the ankle

Temperature Rating: Not stated

Footwear Closure: Slip on

Waterproof: Yes

What we love: warmth, comfort, softness, ease to slip on and off, quality stitching and materials, rubber sole makes it easy to step outside briefly to run errands or get something out of a vehicle

What we don’t love: it’s a slipper and isn’t waterproof this isn’t the winter boot to wear outside for extended periods

If you want a cozy winter boot to wear around the house, out to run errands, and to slip on after a full day skiing, this is the boot for you. The Glerups Wool Boots with Rubber Soles are a great addition to the winter footwear repertoire, as they are not only warm and comfortable, they have excellent traction and are easy to slip on and off.

We didn’t quite know where to put these boots, but we had to include the Glerups Wool Boots with Rubber Soles because we’re in love with them. We’ve skied and snowshoed them into backcountry huts, brought them glamping and for cabin sleepovers, and otherwise live in these slippers in the winter.

The Glerups with natural colored sole (also available in black). Photo by Josette Deschambeault.

The Glerups with black colored sole (also available in neutral). Photo by Josette Deschambeault.

THERMOREGULATION AND WATERPROOFNESS

The biggest reason why they did not win for our Best for City Walking or Best Slip-On categories are the height of the boot (only about ankle height) and their water resistance, rather than water proofness.

The wool is a great thermo-regulator and thick enough to withstand small splashes of water or puddles, but it’s too easy to submerge them in bigger puddles to count on them as a solid winter boot choice.

However, if you want a cozy winter boot to wear around the house, out to run errands, and to slip on after a full day skiing, this is the boot for you.

Glerups on the back of the truck. These winter booties are our favorite after a day of skiing. Photo by Josette Deschambeault.

These winter booties are our favorite after a day of skiing. Photo by Josette Deschambeault.

SUSTAINABILITY

We also love the story behind these boots — the company works directly with farmers to use wool that is too coarse for most garments and makes sustainable footwear out of wool that would otherwise be discarded. When the farmers first saw a boot made with their sheeps’ wool, they cried. We did, too, when we first put these boots on — tears of joy! (They are available in a black rubber outsole, as well.) 

WHO ELSE LIKES THEM

Multiple Treeline writers and editors find these boots so comfortable that they’ve been known to wear these boots in town, after skiing, and around the house. In fact, hour for hour, we probably spend more time in these boots than any other winter shoe. They’re also a winner in our Best Camp Shoes guide as well as in our Best Gifts for Skiers guides. They’re that good.


Best Affordable Winter Boots: Merrell Thermo Chill mid shell waterproof boots

Insulation: 200 g synthetic

Shaft Height: over ankle

Temperature Rating: not stated

Footwear Closure: lace

Waterproof: Yes

What we liked: price, lightweight, balance of weight, weather protection, comfort, traction

What we didn’t like: midankle height requires gaiters for deep snow

For time spent on snow-packed trails, whether winter hiking or snowshoeing, the Merrell Thermochill Mid Shell Waterproof boot makes an excellent companion and our winner for Best Men's Budget Winter Boot. This lace-up waterproof boot is constructed with a combination of leather and synthetic materials on the upper and hits just above the ankle to keep your feet dry in packed snow. The 200 grams of synthetic insulation packed into the boot kept our feet warm (with a wool sock) even while hiking in single-digit temps in the Colorado high country.

COMFORT

When we tested the Merrell Thermo Chill this winter walking trails and in Colorado ski towns, weight didn't bog us down for how warm these boots kept our feet. At just under 2lbs per pair, these boots get the job done without feeling overly cumbersome, as many winter hiking boots do. They’re not the lightest boots on the market, but we think they offer the ideal balance of weight, weather protection, comfort, and traction.

The Thermo Chill boots boast sturdy, multidirectional rubber lugs. While testing these boots, they gripped hard-packed snow surfaces without issues. Even without traction devices, like microspikes, we felt secure on everything except a pure sheet of ice. For all-around winter trail use, the traction on these boots shines. 

Because these boots hit mid-ankle, we found ourselves reaching for a pair of gaiters when the snow got deeper. But, for the same design reasons, we find this boot to be more versatile in varying conditions than boots that fall higher above the ankle. From stormy, mid-winter snowshoe excursions to sunny and snow-packed hikes, the Thermochill will keep your feet happy.


OTHER WINTER BOOTS WE TESTED

Salomon X Ultra mid winter cs wp 2 waterproof insulated winter boots in black

Salomon X Ultra Mid Winter CS WP 2

Category: Best Traction

Insulation: Yes

Waterproof: Yes

We’re looking forward to testing the Salomon X Ultra Mid Winter CS Waterproof 2. It’s a waterproof and insulated version of the winner in our guides for Best Hiking Shoes and Best Lightweight Hiking Boots.

The Salomon X Ultras have received rave reviews from Switchback Travel and Cleverhiker.

What we liked: Super light and just enough warmth to keep your feet toasty on the trail, these are a solid winner for winter hiking, thanks to the 200-gram fill and 7-inch shaft height. 

What we didn’t like: Pretty narrow, and not great for keeping warm during low-output activities. 


Baffin impact winter boots for men in black for extreme cold

Baffin Impact Boots

Category: Extreme Cold

Insulation: Yes

Waterproof: Yes

What we liked: These are the ideal work boots for extremely low temperatures. 

What we didn’t like: Hard to walk in and barely breathable. 

The Baffin Impact Boots are an extremely warm boot to keep you toasty even in the extreme cold. It gets nods from Switchback Travel and Clever Hiker for its warmth.

The Baffin boots are the most expensive of any we considered for this guide. However, if you find yourself needing winter boots that are extremely warm, it may be worth it.


Do I need different boots for winter than I do for hiking? We’ve got answers. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

Do I need different boots for winter than I do for hiking? We’ve got answers. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

Why do you need Winter Boots? 

If you’re asking this question, you may not live above the Mason-Dixon line. (Kidding — my family in Tennessee have warmer snow boots than I do!)

What you’re probably asking is, do I need different boots for winter than I do for hiking? (see below).

Or, are there other options besides insulated snow boots? We’re here to answer yes to both of those questions. 

Compared with a hiking boot, winter boots are designed to:

  • Be waterproof (from snow, sleet, hail, slush, ice, and all other forms of frozen water)

  • Durable, even after prolonged exposure to moisture

  • Hold traction against icy walkways

  • Keep your feet from freezing.


How should Winter Boots fit?

This might be the trickiest question to answer. While you want your winter boots to fit well (read: not falling off of your feet and not squeezing them tight), a lot depends on the thickness of your winter socks. 

In general, when you try on winter boots, you want to wear a thick sock (like a heavy wool sock), then try them on again with a thinner sock (like a ski sock). That way you can find the in-between for when you wear your boots with different sock thicknesses.

If you have wide feet, look for models that are better for molding to wider feet or opt for a wide option. Photo by Josette Deschambeault

If you have wide feet, look for models that are better for molding to wider feet or opt for a wide option. Photo by Josette Deschambeault

You want to find a happy medium where your boots have a little wiggle room but aren’t too roomy. As with any other shoe you try on, walk around in them to make sure that the heels aren’t rubbing, your toes aren’t cramped, that you have ample ankle support (should they be over-the-ankle-boots), and nothing hurts. 

Women’s heels tend to be slimmer, and their ankles smaller than men’s. Women’s boots, therefore, are generally designed to be slimmer in the heel to fit better and reduce slippage. If you have wide feet, however, keep in mind that some boots come in wide options, or are better for molding to wider feet. (Sorels, for instance, generally run big!) 


Some of the winter boots we tested. Photo by Josette Deschambeault.

Some of the winter boots we tested. Photo by Josette Deschambeault.

Buying advice 

Warmth

It was clear to us that winter boots should—hold onto your hats, folks—keep your feet warm. As the biggest differentiation between hiking boots and winter boots, we looked at reviews for the best insulated and non-insulated boots to make sure that your toes would stay toasty in all sorts of winter weather. 

Tread

For our best winter boot winners, we wanted to make sure that each pair of boots we chose had good tread for ice, snow, slush, and a mixture in between. While we have a separate winner for Best Winter Boot for Traction and Best Overall, tread was one of our top considerations while researching winter boots. 

Waterproofness

With cold weather comes snow, ice, hail, and all sorts of other fun water-cycles. We dove into the waterproofness of each boot we researched to make sure that, not only was the waterproofing system used effective, but that it lasted longer than the first snow day. Check out our section on how to waterproof your boots, just in case you start to feel some snow leaking in. 

Fit

While this might be the most relative (not every foot is the same, right?) we wanted to make sure that our winners had positive reviews when it came to fit, as well as function. We looked for boots that were comfortable, didn’t produce blisters, weren’t too heavy or clunky, and worked well with different thicknesses of socks. Check out our How Should My Boots Fit section for more help on this subject. 

Why winter boots are better than hiking boots in winter.

Height is one reason why winter boots are better than hiking boots in winter.

Height

While most people are looking for mid-calf or higher winter boots, some just want to make sure their ankles are covered. We looked for winter boots with a range of heights, to make sure that all fashions, functions, and fits were represented as best that we could. 

Breathability

Breathability is one thing that you might sacrifice with a winter boot. While we do love semi-breathable materials for winter hiking boots (like the Merrell Thermo Chill Mid boots, with their mesh uppers), breathability is usually at odds with waterproofness and warmth — two very key components of winter boots.

While non-breathable boots like the XtraTuf Legacy 15” boots aren’t for everyone (they get stinky pretty quickly), they’re purely waterproof and have insulated options. However, other boots like the Sorel Caribous have felt liners that both insulate and can help keep your toes from sweating too much on warmer snow days. 

Removable Liners 

Removable liners are a godsend. As with the author’s Sorel Joan of Arctic boots, it’s the felt liners that will give out before the waterproof suede and vulcanized rubber exteriors will. Removable liners give you the ability to dry your winter boots out more efficiently (read: faster) and keep them from stinking up. If at all possible, we recommend a winter boot with a removable liner to keep you dry, warm, and stink-free. 

Weight

Winter boots tend to run heavy, which makes sense — insulation weighs more than light, breathable materials. The soles of winter boots are usually thicker with deep tread for better traction, which also adds on the ounces. Take into account how much extra weight you’re willing to carry on your feet — weigh the benefit of additional information or hardier tread against how that extra weight will tire you out more easily. 

Type of Insulation

Our boot picks used a myriad of insulation materials, from the charcoal and bamboo used in the Merrell Thermo Chill Mids to the Thinsulate used in the Blundstone 500’s. Other boots use more thick, natural fibers like the pure wool in the UGG Butte, while some have very little like the thin polymeric foam of the XtraTuf Legacy Insulated boots. How much insulation you need directly correlates with the temperatures you plan to explore. The colder the climate, the better (and thicker) the insulation should be. Check out each of our picks to find out why we like the insulation for each boot. 


Three different models of winter boots. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

Three different models of winter boots. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

How to Choose the Winter Boot for You

Do you want to hike or snowshoe in these boots?

Our winner for Best Traction and Ankle Support Boot would be a great option. They have great tread, are tall enough to keep out snow as you’re walking (or pair well with gaiters for extended snowshoe trips), and will make sure you don’t roll your ankles. 

If you want to wear your boot in snowshoes, consider something with more support.

If you are mostly hiking, you may be able to get away with some Hiking Boots or even Lightweight Hiking Boots depending on temperatures and conditions.

Do you live somewhere with extremely cold weather? 

Check out our Best Overall winner or our Best for Extreme Cold boots. Both are stuffed with super warm insulation and are designed to keep you dry and warm. If you’re looking for something a little more rugged, check out our Best Insulated Slip-On Boots. They’re super warm, waterproof, and hardy enough to tackle any job you have. 

Do you walk through heavy or wet snow? 

We would recommend our Best Insulated Slip-On Boots (if it’s very cold), Best Non-Insulated Slip-On Boots (if it’s very wet), or our Best Overall winner (if it’s very snowy and cold). 

Do you have a lot of snow in your area? 

Choose a boot with a taller shaft to keep that snow off of your feet. Try our Best Overall winner for a taller height, faux fur ruff, and waterproof sealed seams. 

Do your feet get cold easily? 

It depends on what style you’re looking for, and what you want to do. If you’re worried about fashion choices, then check out our Overall Best Men’s Winter Boots Winner or our Best for City Walking winner (the insulated Bean duck boot might just do the trick!). But if your feet get extremely cold, our Best for Extreme Cold boots would be a better option. 

Do your feet overheat easily? 

Try a non-insulated option, like our Best Non-Insulated Slip-On Boots, or our Best for Ciy Walking options. A little bit of insulation might be nice, but don’t overdo it.

Are you traveling somewhere cold for vacation? 

If you live some place warm but are going on a ski trip or headed somewhere cooler, check out our Best Budget winner! Without breaking the bank (or exceeding the airline’s weight limit), you can have a great pair of winter boots that will serve you well for that weeklong ski trip. 

Do you need extra ankle or arch support? 

Then our Best Traction and Ankle Support Boot might just be the ticket. 

Do you want a more fashionable winter boot? 

We have a Best for City Walking winner just for you. But maybe you want something taller and warmer? Go for our Best Overall Winner. Trying to work outdoors in the winter, but don’t want to compromise warmth for fashion? Look at our Best Non-Insulated Slip-On Boots

Do you want a winter boot for outdoor work? 

Then our Best Slip-On options might just do the trick for you. We have both insulated and non-insulated options for any outdoor weather. Or, if it’s bound to be colder, maybe the Best for Extreme Cold winner!


Caribou vs Bean Boots on two people

insulated vs non-insulated winter boots

It’s a much-asked question—do I need an insulated boot or will uninsulated waterproof boots work for me? Here are some pros and cons for each type of boot and our thoughts on the types of people and conditions where you may prefer one boot over the other.

Why Choose Insulated Winter Boots?

REI’s article, Best Winter Boots, linked out to a great article explaining why women tend to have colder feet than men. (We found another article that doesn’t make you pay to read it.) But it’s scientific: women’s body temperatures tend to run higher than men’s. While you’d think we’d feel warmer because of that, the opposite is true. When you’re used to being warm, your body feels temperature differences more acutely. 

Insulation like Thinsulate, Primaloft, shearling, fleece, and neoprene can ensure your toes stay warm. Even if you don’t want to overheat your feet, your toes are one of the furthest extremities from your heart, and they need a little help to stay warmer in extreme temperatures. In an insulated boot, look for thick soles that keep your feet away from the snow and ice, and ruffs around the top to trap snow before it falls down towards your feet. 

Why Choose Non-insulated Winter Boots?

As an Alaska resident, I’ve known cold. And I’ve known rain. Sometimes those two things coincided, with 40-degree deluges instead of nice fluffy snow at 30-degree weather. Sometimes, all I need is a winter boot that will keep my toes moderately warm but will really keep the water, snow, and slush out. 99% of the time — including shoveling, skiing, hiking, snowmobiling, walking, and working — I wear uninsulated rubber boots throughout the winter. 

Wearing the Xtratuf Uninsulated Boots at a Broncos game. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

Wearing the Xtratuf Uninsulated Boots at a Broncos game. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

If you’re like me, you might tend to run warm, and nothing’s worse for me than walking in from a 15-degree day to an 80-degree waiting room. I appreciate winter for the cold, not for being hot. So on an average day, I can’t stand to wear insulated boots because I’ll simply be too hot running errands, going to work, or going out to eat. Even with uninsulated boots, I still have a degree of warmth and a healthy degree of waterproofness that won’t make my feet feel like they’re swimming in a sauna. 

Living in Colorado’s Front Range, insulated boots are overkill for me for all but 3 days out of the year. Since the Front Range tends to run warm — a recent 45 degree, sunny day had me in a tank top, after all — I tend to choose my footwear based on their effectiveness throughout the different seasons. I can wear an uninsulated pair of boots throughout the fall and spring, as well as in the dead of winter. How can I do this? It all comes down to the socks that I wear with them. On days above freezing, I can wear thinner socks, while frigid days have me pulling out my thick wool socks. As long as you find a pair of uninsulated boots that can accommodate different thicknesses of socks, you’ll have a pair of boots that prove to be far more versatile across a range of temperatures and conditions.

WHAT SOCKS SHOULD I WEAR WITH MY WINTER BOOTS?

Warm ones! Seriously, though, there are so many sock options to choose from that we’ll stick to the basics — find warm socks that fit well (not too loose and not too tight) that will still fit into your boots. While the author is a big fan of ski socks for most of her winter activities (like the merino wool Icebreaker Ski+ socks), thick, cushioned socks like the REI Co-op Merino Wool Expedition Hiking Crew Socks have served me well in subzero temperatures when paired with a good winter boot.


Muck Boots vs. Bogs

One of the biggest questions from reviewers was, “Why Muck over Bogs?” 

Our research shows that Muck Boots are way warmer. We found more reviews overall and more positive reviews for the Muck Boot Arctic Sport II’s when it comes to use in harsh winter conditions. The rubber soles on the Arctic Sport II’s are thicker than Boggs insulation, which insulates you more effectively from the cold ground. They have more insulation (remember that 5mm of the stuff?) to boot. 

Similarly, Outdoor Gear Lab called found that Muck Boots outperformed their Boggs counterparts in a few areas: “Let's start with the pros: good arch support, cushiony insole, neoprene shaft that provides good mobility, and a fleecy lining that adds comfort. Now, on to the cons: the sole is thick and stiff, it's one of the heaviest/bulkiest in the review, and there's a fair amount of heel slippage. Overall, we liked walking in the Bogs Classic High better because of its lower, more flexible sole, but the Muck Boots do provide more arch support and have the fleecy lining.”

In the end, it’s a personal preference and somewhat of a regional preference (some people are die-hard Bogs fans, some Muckboot fans). Our best advice is to choose the boots for your needs and that fit in with your locale.


Xtratufs on the back of the truck. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

Xtratufs, LL Bean Boots, and Glerups winter slippers side-by-side on the snowy porch. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

care and maintenance

Winter boots are an essential investment for cold and wet conditions, but to ensure they last and perform well throughout the season, proper care and maintenance are crucial. You can also learn more in our section on Care and Maintenance for Hiking Boots

Here are some tips and guidelines to help you keep your winter boots in top shape:

Cleaning and storage tips

Regular cleaning

After each use, remove any dirt, mud, or salt residue from your boots. Use a soft brush or a damp cloth to gently clean the exterior. For stubborn stains, consider using a boot cleaner or a mixture of mild soap and water. Always follow the manufacturer's cleaning recommendations.

Can you put winter boots in the washing machine and dryer?

Short answer? No. Winter boots are not meant to be tossed around or fully submerged into water, so putting them in the washing machine or dryer is a bad idea. 

Drying

Never leave your wet boots near a direct heat source like a radiator or a heater, as excessive heat can damage the materials. Instead, remove the insoles and let the boots air dry at room temperature. Stuffing them with newspaper can help absorb moisture and maintain their shape.

WATERPROOFING

Nikwax Waterproofer

Like jackets, bibs, and gloves, your boots might eventually wear out their waterproofness. To keep the water-repellent properties of your boots strong, prep them with a waterproofing wax (we love Nikwax and Sno Seal!) before the first snow of the season. (Think of it like putting snow tires on your car before the roads get icy.)

Before applying any waterproofing substances, you should make sure that your boots are clean and dry. Mountain Warehouse has a great guide on how to clean and waterproof leather, suede/nubuck, and fabric boots. 

Once your boots are clean, use a hairdryer (or set them near a wood stove, if you’re old-school!) to warm up everything above the sole. If you choose a Nikwax product, they advise that you do not warm your boots before or after applying the wax. (Room temperature is ideal.) If you’re applying Sno Seal, however, they recommend warming your boots up to 120 °F, maximum (or to your comfort level as you’re handling the boots). Note: DO NOT PUT YOUR BOOTS IN THE OVEN! Use a hairdryer.

With a clean rag, coat and rub as much of the waterproofing wax into your boots as you can. Concentrate on seams and high-use areas (like under the laces or by the zipper, if your boots have those), as these are the most likely to lose their waterproofing. Wipe off excess wax with a clean rag and buff off any remaining wax. Let it sit overnight for best results, but if you’re in a hurry to head outside, you’ll still be covered! 

STORAGE

Re-waterproofing is just part of the maintenance you should expect to do several times over the life of your winter boots.

Re-waterproofing is just part of the maintenance you should expect to do several times over the life of your winter boots.

When the snows melt and it’s time to start thinking about flip-flops, make sure that your boots are clean and completely dry.

Putting your winter boots away wet enables mold and bacteria to grow during the warmer months. Ideally, wrapping them up and storing them in a clean, dry box for the summer is the best practice.

If you’re like me and don’t have my storage on lock (aka under your bed is your only storage), wrapping them in a garbage bag also works well. Just be sure they have had a chance to completely dry beforehand. 

Maintaining your waterproofing and insulation

Inspect seams and stitching

Periodically check the seams and stitching of your boots for any signs of wear or damage. Repair any loose threads or small tears promptly to prevent water from seeping in.

Reapply waterproofing

If you notice that water is no longer beading up on the surface of your boots, it's time to reapply the waterproofing treatment. Follow the manufacturer's instructions, and consider doing this before each winter season.

Maintain insulation

Insulation materials like Thinsulate or PrimaLoft can lose their effectiveness if compressed or soaked. Avoid over-tightening laces, as this can compress insulation. If your boots get soaked, remove the insoles and let them dry completely to maintain insulation performance.

Replacing worn-out soles or insoles

Check for Sole wear

The soles of your winter boots can wear down over time, affecting traction and comfort. If you notice significant sole wear or loss of grip, consider having them resoled by a professional cobbler. This can extend the life of your boots significantly.

REPLACE YOUR INSOLES

If the stock insoles of your boots become worn or lose their cushioning, replace them with high-quality aftermarket insoles. This can enhance comfort and support, especially if you spend long hours in your boots. Aren’t sure whether you should use insoles? See our thoughts on the pros and cons of using an aftermarket insole with your shoes.

By following these care and maintenance tips, you can prolong the lifespan of your men's winter boots and ensure they continue to provide the protection and comfort you need during the cold and wet seasons. Proper care not only extends the life of your boots but also enhances their performance, keeping your feet warm, dry, and comfortable in challenging winter conditions.


Two pairs of winter boots on the tailgate of a pickup truck.

Two pairs of winter boots on the tailgate of a pickup truck.

FAQ

CAN I USE HIKING BOOTS IN THE WINTER?

While hiking boots can do in a pinch, most of them aren’t insulated like a winter boot. Hiking boots can have great tread and be waterproof, but are they what you want to wear when you have to shovel out the neighborhood after a blizzard? Probably not. For starters, they might not have the insulation that you want as protection against all of that snow you’re shoveling. Or the tread might be great for dirt and rock, but not for ice. Above all, your hiking boots just might not be tall enough to keep the snow from falling into your socks, which nobody wants.

While hiking boots will do in a pinch (say, a snowstorm in South Florida?) anyone who’s planning for multiple days of snow per season should also plan on owning a pair of winter boots.

In some parts of the world, you may only need waterproof protection or the lightest bit of insulation. Maybe you only need winter boots for 3 days every year. (Looking at you, Tennessee.) In other parts — like Japan, Vermont, Utah, or Austria — you might need winter boots with insulation (or height to clear those snowdrifts) for 6 months of the year. We have options for all of these scenarios! 

Are winter boots good for hiking?

Some winter boots can be! To work well as hiking boots, you want your winter boots to have great tread, ankle support, and flexibility.

If you’re hiking in winter, your best bets are our winners for:

If you mostly hike in summer but may do a hike in winter, you may not want to dish out for a winter hiking boot. If that’s the case, choose a waterproof hiking boot from our Best Lightweight Hiking Boots or Best Hiking Boots guide. These won’t have the insulation but should be able to keep your feet dry.

Are all winter boots waterproof?

Not all winter boots are waterproof. While some are designed with waterproof materials and features, others are water-resistant. Look for boots labeled as "waterproof" if you need protection from wet conditions.

What's the difference between synthetic and leather winter boots?

Synthetic boots are often more affordable and can be very waterproof, but they may not breathe as well as leather. Leather boots tend to be more durable and offer better breathability, but they may require more maintenance.

How can I prevent my winter boots from smelling bad?

To prevent odor, allow your boots to dry completely between uses, use moisture-wicking socks, and consider using odor-fighting insoles or inserts. You can also sprinkle baking soda inside your boots to absorb odors.

How do I clean salt stains off my winter boots?

To remove salt stains, mix equal parts of water and white vinegar, then apply the solution to the stains with a cloth or sponge. Wipe off any excess and let the boots dry naturally. Follow up with a waterproofing treatment.

How can I test the waterproofing of my boots?

To test waterproofing, fill a bathtub or basin with water and submerge your boots for a few minutes. If any water seeps in, it's time to reapply waterproofing treatment or consider warranty coverage if applicable.

Do winter boots require a break-in period?

Some boots may require a short break-in period to conform to your feet, but many modern models are comfortable right out of the box. It's essential to prioritize comfort from the beginning.


How we Researched

To ensure that we reviewed the best boots for this snowy season, we researched the most popular winter boots and came up with over 50 different choices. We sorted the top contenders into our eight groups:

The eight winners were popular and well-reviewed across different platforms, from third parties such as Outside Magazine, New York Times/Wirecutter, Forbes, Gear Junkie, and Outdoor Gear Lab.

In addition, each of these winter boots was thoroughly reviewed and highly recommended by everyday users on platforms such as REI, Backcountry.com, and Amazon.

From these latter sites, we verified reviews against FakeSpot, a site which flags falsified or tampered reviews, to verify authenticity.

After review of outdoor media, real-life customer feedback, our own expertise, and comments from outdoor professionals who make their living on snow, we narrowed a list of over 50 promising boots down to our top eight winners.

To be considered for each of these categories, we measured each pair of boots against standardized criteria: have good tread, be waterproof, have a great fit, be a snow-proof height. Most importantly, they had to be considered warm by a majority of customer reviews. From there, we narrowed our criteria to our specific categories — for example, with our best traction winner, we ran all of our boots through a list of features valued by hardcore winter hikers, those who live in incredibly icy areas, and those who wanted versatility across any terrain.


How we judged the Best Winter Boots

From the hundreds of winter boots on the market, we knew we had to cull the posers from the real deals. We wanted boots that could withstand the range of weather conditions that winter can throw our way. We researched the best boots for icy conditions, wet conditions, snowy conditions, and extreme cold conditions that were comfortable, provided good arch support, and were waterproof. We also wanted to find high-quality, durable materials without breaking the bank. 

As we researched, we narrowed our criteria to meet five main themes: warmth, tread, waterproofness, fit, and height.

Our winners met all of our basic criteria. Then, we judged each pair of boots relative to its own specific criteria. For example, for the Best Budget Boots, they needed to be warm, comfortable, over the ankle, and reasonably durable at an affordable price. Our Best Traction and Ankle Support Boots had to have great ankle and arch support, combined with a killer tread for icy conditions. We also wanted to provide options for the Best Slip-On Boots in both insulated and non-insulated options and present the pros and cons of both. 


The author in her winter boots. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

The author in her winter boots. Photo courtesy Josette Deschambeault.

Author’s Expertise: Why you should trust us

Cold is no stranger to me. I grew up in Colorado with New York-expat parents and spent winters in Alaska, Maine, and New Hampshire. I’m no stranger to cold feet. I wouldn’t give up the cold for a sunny beach day, ever — but I do prefer to keep my toes warm. And having owned 4 of the 6 chosen boots, I can safely say that I know what works — and what doesn’t.

I’ve skied for most of my life, from New England hills to hometown Colorado resorts, and backcountry adventures in Japan, Alaska, British Columbia, and the Yukon. Additionally, I’ve been a backpacking, rock climbing, hiking, and rafting guide in Alaska and Colorado; many of my “summer” seasons up north began when there was snow on the ground and ice blocking my boats from going downriver. Spending 3 years on volunteer fire departments in Alaska and Maine have sent me out on Search and Rescue calls on frigid winter nights, ambulance calls in 4’ snowdrifts, and fire calls where water would freeze as soon as it left the hose.
My gear expertise stems from 6 years of gear reviews for Backpacker Magazine, 6 years of guiding, 26 years of cold-weather adventures, and a plethora of gear-head friends. In addition, I’ve written outdoor lifestyle pieces for REI’s Uncommon Path Magazine and Powder 7 Ski Shop’s Lift Line Blog. (For additional publications and upcoming articles, check out my website.) 

Let it be known: no one in my family (including myself) is sponsored, an ambassador, or an employee of any of the companies mentioned here. This is unbiased, and we do this to help you find the best product for the price. Treeline Review doesn’t accept sponsored content, native advertising, or paid reviews.

You can read all of my articles on my author page.


Sources